Mark's Pizzeria, nestled at 203A Lake St in Penn Yan, NY, has quickly become a beloved go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts. Customers rave about the fluffy dough, expertly crafted to create a light yet satisfying crust that pairs beautifully with just the right amount of sauce. David Enser's experience highlights the diverse menu, from their delectable calzones and garden salads to their perfectly cooked wings, all served hot and fresh. Emma Broussard echoes this sentiment, declaring the pizza some of the best she’s ever had, even loving the taste of it as leftovers.
What truly sets Mark's Pizzeria apart, however, is its exceptional customer service. Joy Benson emphasizes the staff's dedication to correcting mistakes and providing a warm and friendly atmosphere. Even during a busy night, Seth S found the manager to be approachable and pleasant, contributing to an overall positive dining experience. Additionally, Myah Lupo's praise for their delivery service shows that Mark's extends their commitment to quality beyond the restaurant itself.
In summary, Mark's Pizzeria not only delivers flavorful dishes but also fosters a welcoming environment that keeps patrons coming back for more. Next time you’re in Penn Yan, don’t miss the chance to indulge in a slice of their remarkable pizza!
Amenities and More
Service options
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Sport
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Gender-neutral toilets
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Groups
University students
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Photos
Reviews For Mark's Pizzeria
David Enser
Jul 10,2025
Stayed in Penn Yan on business. Found Mark's Pizzeria. Ordered a Calzone and Garden Salad the first night; Wings, Garden Salad and a Slice of Pizza the second night - fresh, hot and tasty! Definitely enjoyed the overall experience ... felt the prices were more than fair, friendly service made me feel like they appreciated my business and wanted me to come back. Looking forward to my next visit!
Emma Broussard
Jul 4,2025
Visiting NY from TX and this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! Love the crust, just the right amount of sauce, even the leftovers were delicious.
Seth S
Jul 4,2025
Great pizza! If you love Mark's dough then you already know. If you haven't been, Mark's has some pretty fluffy dough. It's super tasty, great flavor and it's very light. This isn't super NY style if you've every had pizza in NYC but I grew up eating it and love Mark's. I also love the granny's fried dough! Sooo good! I gave this location 5 stars, it had clearly been a long day and the manager/pizza maker was still friendly. Pizza came out great exactly as I had hoped!
Joy Benson
Jun 17,2025
I've had nothing but good experiences with Mark's. Even when mistakes have been made with my order, the staff always goes above and beyond to correct them. Everyone is always friendly. Great customer service!
Myah Lupo
May 28,2025
Delivery driver came all the way out to our construction site. Very impressed with service and food. Will order from there again!!
Mark B.
Apr 22,2025
Thank you for delivering to me out in the middle of nowhere, you can count on the cheese pizza. Subs and calzones are also huge and delicious! Whoever took our order did a great job repeating our order to verify everything was correct. Thanks again!
Sydney Pellman
Apr 14,2025
I ordered for a whole volleyball team and Mark’s Pizzeria was excellent. I called and made a last minute change from pickup to delivery and they happily adjusted everything for me. Rachel delivered our order and she was super helpful in bringing it all the way into the gym for us. Will definitely be ordering here again if we’re back in the area!
Darkness Your Old Friend
Mar 16,2025
5 stars, just cause we love love there cheesy bread sticks, and the got the sauces right!!!
Reviews For Mark's Pizzeria